Why Jagr makes more sense than Iginla for the Kings

Iginla vs Jagr LA Kings MayorsManor
If there’s one thing you’ve probably learned about MayorsManor through the years it’s that we don’t waste much time on trade rumors. Such articles are great for driving traffic to a website, but they’re also a maddening exercise that usually bears very little fruit. Instead, we prefer to deal with real stories, not hypothetical ones.

Occasionally though, there are scenarios where we can approach things from a ‘hockey’ perspective. Think of it as the written equivalent to those long sought after ‘hockey trades’ – not trades where teams are dumping salary or trades where teams are trying to acquire draft pics, but deals that are mutually beneficial.

So, that’s what today’s article is, a mutually beneficial discussion.

We’ve been asked repeatedly about the Kings’ possible interest in Jarome Iginla.  With the NHL Trade Deadline just a week away, let’s talk about it.

When faced with similar situations in the past we offered helpful articles (or at least we thought so).

Before the Kings hired Darryl Sutter as head coach – while the rest of the media was ridiculing the idea – we offered an article explaining why the hire would make a lot of sense (read it here).

Then, we doubled down last spring. As everybody else was talking about Rick Nash to the Kings, we wrote why Jeff Carter was actually the smarter move (read that one here).

Now, we’re going for the hat trick of sorts, as we’ll tell you why Jaromir Jagr would be a much better fit of the Kings than Iginla.

On the surface, one usually wouldn’t write an article saying a 41-year old forward should be the preferred trade target for the defending Stanley Cup Champions looking to stock up before a second run – especially when the other option is a young player who scored 43 goals just two seasons ago.

But, Jagr is many things. Typical isn’t one of them.

To start with, let’s look at value.

Neither player is signed beyond this season, so salary cap isn’t a major issue.

The rumored price for Iginla is three assets, most likely two top-end prospects and a draft pick.

On the other side, the Stars have talked about wanting to resign Jagr. However, they haven’t done it, and in the right deal, he’s still available.

So, what would he cost a team?

Here’s what it won’t cost – Jonathan Bernier, Tyler Toffoli and a draft pick.

If that’s what the Flames are asking for, why would Dean Lombardi give up two of his most valuable assets for a rental player? Even for a second run at the Cup, that’s a very steep price to pay.

The Kings would be better off trading ‘lesser’ prospects and/or picks for Jagr.

Forget the fact that LA seems to need Bernier now more than ever before, given the erratic play (at times) of Jonathan Quick this season. Forget the fact that Toffoli will likely be a consistent 30-goal scorer in the NHL. Forget the fact that the Kings biggest need right now is on defense, not offense.  Just know that if you’re moving assets of that caliber, you better be getting back more than a rental player in return.

The quick retort from some is, ‘Well just sign Iginla to an extension.’ There’s one minor (read: major) problem with that line of thinking. The salary cap is coming DOWN next season and the Kings have plenty of contracts to deal with already.  Even if you assume Dustin Penner is coming off the books, they still need to re-sign Slava Voynov and re-sign/replace Rob Scuderi. Then, there’s all the RFA’s Lombardi will need to re-sign too.

The bidding for Iginla will be high. Several teams in the Eastern Conference want him. More importantly, the Flames are seeking a large ransom for him because (a) he’s their captain and (b) if they more the face of the franchise, they need to show that it was ‘worth it’ to their fan-base.

The same can’t be said in Dallas. Jagr just signed their last summer. He doesn’t have any deep ties to the franchise.

Although he’s been a popular player over the past three months, their fan-base already knows they’re in a modified rebuild mode. Their GM just traded Brenden Morrow to the Pittsburgh Penguins. Nobody is going to riot in Dallas if Jagr is moved.

Plus, at 6-foot-3, 240 pounds, he’s exactly the type of player the Kings love adding to their line-up.

Best of all, Jagr’s production has been stellar this year – not only in the games against the Kings, where he has been phenomenal, but overall.  His 14 goals (and 25 points in 31 games) are well ahead of Iginila’s nine goals.

Finally, and this point is a possibility, not a guarantee.  Iginla has been ‘the man’ in Calgary for more than a decade.  He wouldn’t be that in LA.  Would that be a plus or a minus?  How would he adjust?  Nobody knows for sure.  However, we already have the answer with Jagr.  He knows what it’s like to be part of a team rather than the guy carrying the mail.

On balance, the best trades come with a sense of value.

Iginla is a great talent, there’s no denying that point.

When you weigh it all out though, a trade for Jagr makes much more sense for the Kings.

RELATED CONTENT:  Dean Lombardi – ‘Bernier trade not feasible, he’s too valuable’

Note to webmasters/reporters: When recapping news or interviews from this site please include a link to www.MayorsManor.com

Recent Articles

TSN REPLAY: Hoven Breaks Down the LA Kings, Mike Futa Situation

Follow @mayorNHL
Enjoy a free replay of John Hoven on TSN Radio, where he joined host Kevin Olszewski to discuss several NHL related topics – including what went down this week between the Kings and Mike Futa.
Today’s radio segment can be heard using the player below or download any previous appearances for free on the MayorsManor […]

LA Kings 2020 Prospect Rankings – Players No. 7 and 8

It’s time for another pair of prospect reports! After revealing the first two players inside the Top 10 last week, we’re back with another pair of future Kings – and both are defensemen.
For anybody new to our rankings, know that you’ve come to the right place. Many view this as the definitive guide to the […]

LA Kings 2020 Prospect Rankings – Players No. 9 and 10

We hear that all of our loyal readers are bored these days. They’ve caught up on all their Netflix shows and are ready to get after some hockey related reading. So, here we are. Like your favorite pair of jeans or a cozy blanket. We’re back with the latest round of prospect reports.
In all seriousness, […]

Major News Items

LA Kings 2020 Prospect Rankings – Goalie Depth Chart

Before we get started here, some context… While normally our Midseason Prospect Rankings come out shortly after the World Junior Championships, we held off in anticipation of any deals the Kings may make prior to the … [Read More...]

More Prospect News

About John Hoven

John Hoven is a member of the of the Professional Hockey Writers Association and co-hosts Kings of the Podcast. He is also the founder and editor of MayorsManor.com, which has been named Best Sports Blog in Los Angeles by LA Weekly and Hockey Blog of the Year by Yahoo Sports. Click "ABOUT OUR TEAM" above for a full bio.


  1. Also, LA already has a lot of right handed players on the top two lines. Carter, Brown, and Williams. Iginla would make a fourth righty. Jagr would be a better option as he is great on the off (right) wing.

  2. A logical look at A potential trade? No, we can’t have that. We must light our hair on fire and run around shouting, “Trade Toffoli and Bernier for Iginla!”. That’s the effect the trade deadline seems to have on seemingly logical people.

    Props to you Mayor, for keeping it real for once.

  3. Eva Marie Alonzo says:

    (The Kings would be better off trading ‘lesser’ prospects and/or picks for Jagr.)
    – In your opinion, who would the ‘lesser’ prospects be?

  4. Kostamojen says:

    While I’m not saying a top-6 winger wouldn’t be a welcomed addition, I really feel that Lombardi should be concentrating his focus on a stay-at-home defenseman. That being said, I’d take Jagr over Iginla any day of the week.

  5. 1. Why would the Stars move a guy with term, within conference? That makes zero sense.

    2. The reported ask (see Pierre Lebrun) for Iginla is guys like Martin Jones, Linden Vey or Tanner Pearson, not Toffoli or Bernier.

    • John Hoven says:

      From what I’ve been told, it’s not likely the Kings could land Iginla without including Bernier in the deal.

      And Tanner Pearson would be an absolute deal breaker. The Kings are VERY thin at LW and upper management sees him as one of their top tier prospects overall. They’re extremely high on Pearson. So, can’t see him included in the deal at all.

    • John Hoven says:

      As for the first question, NHL realignment is coming next season and they won’t be in the same division anymore. With the new playoff format, it won’t matter as much.

    • KingOfRedlands says:

      And also, Jagr is a UFA at the end of the season. Hence, if he wanted to sign with the Kings for the 2013-14 season it wouldn’t be up to the Stars anyways.

  6. Gabby Vyskocil says:

    You’ve convinced me. And your track record is more than decent. All right—I’m on board. Jags to the Kings.

  7. I really, really hope the Kings don’t trade Toffoli. I feel like we always trade away our prospects.

    Oh what do I know? Dean is definitely smarter than me. In Dean we trust.

    • Kostamojen says:

      I don’t think Dean would ever consider trading Toffoli, Pearson, or Bernier as part of a package for a rental player. I also hope to see Toffoli and Pearson as long-term fits with the Kings. If these prospects continue to develop well, some combinations of the following forwards could end up being a very handsome top-6 group:


  8. KingOfRedlands says:

    Jagr makes sense.
    Dallas won’t miss him, the Kings can trade a second rounder (possibly by trading another cheap prospect for a second rounder) and a medium level prospect (depending a lot on what Dallas wants) while maintaining the full roster and strengthening the core.
    Iginla is just too much.
    Thats not to say that Iginla isn’t worth it, he just isn’t worth that to the Kings. The value that the Kings have on a player like Bernier for the rest of the season, far exceeds what other teams value him at.

    I think that Bernier’s RFA rights will get traded to somewhere he wants to go at the end of the season for a first rounder in this draft (replace the one that we traded to Columbus).

  9. Make it happen, Mayor. Move Jags to the Kings and we’ll be unstoppable. (Maybe he can play defense?)

  10. i feel that maybe DAL won’t want to trade within a division. and it looks like he may sign an ext. so its all just rumors and predictions here.

  11. Tina Corpus says:

    I have never been a Jagr fan. I would go as far as to say I can’t stand him. With that said, I would rather have him on the Kings than to have to play against him! He has been a thorn in our side with Dallas this season.


  1. […] – Why Jagr makes more sense for the Kings than Iginla […]

  2. […] RELATED CONTENT:   Why a Jaromir Jagr trade make sense for the LA Kings […]